| A fiduciary is a person who occupies a position of trust in relation to someone else such that he is required to act
for the latter's benefit within the scope of that relationship. In business or
law, it generally means someone with specific duties, such as those that attend a particular
profession or role, e.g., financial analyst or trustee.
Legal considerations
A fiducial relationship does not exist simply because someone places his trust in another person. One must have a reasonable
basis for placing his trust in someone, one that arises from the facts that pertain to that relationship. A court ruled, "Mere
respect for the judgment of another or trust in his character is not enough to constitute such a relationship. There must be such
circumstances as indicate a just foundation for a belief that in giving advice or presenting arguments one is acting not in his
own behalf, but in the interests of another party." (Cranwell v. Oglesby, 12 N.E. 2d 81, 299 Mass. 148, 1937).
Professions
Members of various professions such as physicians, architects, and lawyers, have highly
specialized training, and they often possess credentials that enable them to claim expertise in a particular field. This claim
would tend to constitute a reasonable basis of trust on the part of others who avail themselves of their services, thereby
placing the professional in the position of a fiduciary. Most professions are subject to specific codes of conduct prescribed by
law or independent credentialing authorities (e.g., bar associations or universities).
Other roles
Understood in its broadest terms, one can imagine a number of other fiduciary positions that arise from particular kinds of
relationships, for example, the relationship between employers and employees, investment managers and investors, parents and
children, and so forth. In each case, there the person who is the fiduciary acts for the benefit of people who have a reasonable
basis of placing their trust in them based on the scope of the relationship and the explicit or implict agreement between the
parties as to the terms that govern the relationship.
Moral fiduciary
Some philosophers (see, for example, Michael E. Berumen), argue that everyone who is a moral agent is also a moral fiduciary, because he has a responsibility towards others, namely, to conduct
himself in accordance with moral rules, and that other members of the moral
realm have a reasonable basis for expecting such behavior.
General fiduciary duties
Benjamin Cardozo, while sitting on the Court of Appeals of New York made perhaps the most
famous description of fiduciary duties, stating in his opinion in Salmon v. Chase that they require "the punctilio of an
honor the most sensitive."
The following are encapsulations of duties outlined in Berumen's Do No Evil: Ethics with Applications to Economic Theory
and Business, which would seem to apply to all fiduciary relationships:
- Fiduciaries are responsible for ensuring that they have the necessary knowledge to perform in accordance with their
capacity.
- Fiduciaries must disclose any limitations, conflicts of interest, or barriers to performing their duties.
- Fiduciaries must comply with any legal and professional requirements pertaining to their roles, and also with any relevant
moral strictures.
- Fiduciaries must not take unfair advantage of their relationship (e.g., misuse information) in a way that could have
deleterious effects on those who place their confidence in them.
|