The Munich Agreement and the first Vienna Award
After the Austrian Anschluss, Czechoslovakia was to become Hitler's next target.
Hitler's strategy was to exploit the existing Sudeten German minority problem as a pretext for German penetration into eastern Central Europe (see Germans in Czechoslovakia (1918-1938)). Sudeten German leader Konrad Henlein offered the SdP as the agent for Hitler's campaign. Henlein met
with Hitler in Berlin on March 28, 1938, and
was instructed to raise demands unacceptable to the Czechoslovak government. In the Carlsbad Decrees, issued on April 24, the SdP demanded complete
autonomy for the Sudetenland and freedom to profess Nazi ideology. If Henlein's demands were granted, the Sudetenland would be in a position to align itself with
Nazi Germany.
In 1938 neither Britain nor
France desired war. France, not wanting to face
Germany alone, subordinated itself to Britain. British prime minister Neville Chamberlain became the major spokesman for the West. Chamberlain believed that Sudeten German
grievances were just and Hitler's intention limited. Both Britain and France advised Czechoslovakia to concede. Benes, however, resisted pressure to move toward autonomy or federalism for the
Sudetenland. On May 20, Czechoslovakia initiated a partial mobilization in response to rumours of German troop movements. On May 30, Hitler signed a secret directive for war against Czechoslovakia to begin no later than October 1. The British government demanded that Benes request a mediator. Not wishing to
sever his ties with the West, Benes reluctantly accepted mediation. The British appointed Lord
Runciman as mediator and instructed him to force a solution on Benes that would be acceptable to the Sudeten Germans. On
September 2, Benes submitted the Fourth Plan, which granted nearly all the
demands of the Carlsbad Decrees. Intent on obstructing conciliation, the SdP held a demonstration that provoked police action at
the town of Ostrava on September
7. On September 13, the Sudeten Germans broke off negotiations.
Violence and disruption ensued. Czechoslovak troops attempted to restore order. Henlein flew to Germany and on September 15 issued a proclamation demanding the return of the Sudetenland to
Germany.
On the same day, Hitler met with Chamberlain at Berchtesgaden and
demanded the swift return of the Sudetenland to the Third Reich under threat
of war. The Czechoslovaks, Hitler claimed, were slaughtering the Sudeten Germans. Chamberlain referred the demand to the British
and French governments; both accepted. The Czechoslovak government resisted, arguing that Hitler's proposal would ruin the
nation's economy and lead ultimately to German control of all of Czechoslovakia. Britain and France issued an ultimatum, making
the French commitment to Czechoslovakia contingent upon acceptance. On September 21, Czechoslovakia capitulated. The next day, however, Hitler added new demands, insisting that the
claims of Poland and Hungary for their
minorities also be satisfied.
The Czechoslovak capitulation precipitated an outburst of national indignation. In demonstrations and rallies, the
Czechoslovaks called for a strong military government to defend the integrity of the state. A new cabinet, under General Jan Syrovy, was installed, and on September 23 a decree of general mobilization was issued. The Czechoslovak army, highly modernized and
possessing an excellent system of frontier fortifications, was prepared to fight. The Soviet Union announced its willingness to come to Czechoslovakia's assistance. Benes, however, refused to go
to war without the support of the Western powers. War, he believed, would come soon enough.
On September 28, Chamberlain appealed to Hitler for a conference. Hitler met the next day, at Munich, with the
chiefs of governments of France, Italy, and
Britain. The Czechoslovak government was neither invited nor consulted.
On September 29, the Munich Agreement was signed by Germany, Italy, France, and Britain. The Czechoslovak government
capitulated September 30 and agreed to abide by the agreement. The Munich
Agreement stipulated that Czechoslovakia must cede Sudeten territory to Germany. German occupation of the Sudetenland would be
completed by October 10. An international commission (representing Germany,
Britain, France, Italy, and Czechoslovakia) would supervise a plebiscite to determine the final frontier. Britain and France
promised to join in an international guarantee of the new frontiers against unprovoked aggression. Germany and Italy, however,
would not join in the guarantee until the Polish and Hungarian minority problems were settled.
Benes had resigned as president of the Czechoslovak Republic on October 5,
1938 (and later, after start of WWII created a
government-in-exile in London).
In early November 1938, under the first Vienna Award, which was a result of the Munich agreement, Czechoslovakia (and later Slovakia) was forced by
Germany and Italy to cede southern Slovakia (1/3 of Slovak territory) to Hungary,
and Poland obtained small territorial cessions shortly thereafter.
As a result, Bohemia and Moravia lost
about 38 percent of their combined area, as well as about 2.8 million Germans and
approximately 750,000 Czechs to Germany. Hungary, in turn, received 11,882 square kilometers in southern Slovakia and southern
Ruthenia; only 53 percent of the population in this territory was Hungarian. Poland
acquired the town of Těšín with the surrounding area (some 906 km2, some 250,000 inhabitants, mostly Poles) and two minor border areas in
northern Slovakia, more precisely in the regions Spis and Orava. (226 km2, 4,280 inhabitants, only 0.3 % Poles).
After Munich and Vienna (The Second Republic, October 1938- March 1939)
The greatly weakened Czechoslovak Republic was forced to grant major concessions to the non-Czechs. The executive committee of
the Slovak People's Party met at Zilina on October 5, 1938, and with the acquiescence of all Slovak parties except the Social Democrats formed an autonomous Slovak
government under Jozef Tiso. Similarly, the two major factions in Subcarpathian
Ruthenia, the Russophiles and Ukrainophiles, agreed on the establishment of an autonomous government, which was constituted on
October 8, 1938. Reflecting the spread of modern Ukrainian national consciousness, the pro-Ukrainian faction, led by Volosin,
gained control of the local government, and Subcarpathian Ruthenia was renamed Carpatho-Ukraine.
In November 1938, Emil Hacha, succeeding Benes, was elected president of the
federated Second Republic, renamed Czecho-Slovakia and consisting of three parts: Bohemia + Moravia, Slovakia, and
Carpatho-Ukraine. Lacking its natural frontier and having lost its costly system of border fortification, the new state was
militarily indefensible. In January 1939, negotiations between Germany and Poland broke
down. Hitler, intent on war against Poland, needed to eliminate Czechoslovakia first. He scheduled a German invasion of Bohemia
and Moravia for the morning of March 15. In the interim, he negotiated with the
Slovak People's Party and with Hungary to prepare the dismemberment of the republic before the invasion. On March 13, he invited Jozef Tiso to Berlin
and On March 14, the Slovak Diet convened and unanimously declared Slovak
independence. Carpatho-Ukraine also declared independence, but Hungarian troops occupied it on March 15 and eastern Slovakia on March 23. Hitler summoned President
Hacha to Berlin and during the early hours of March 15, he informed Hacha of the
imminent German invasion. Threatening a Luftwaffe attack on Prague, Hitler persuaded Hacha to order the capitulation of the Czechoslovak army. On the
morning of March 15, German troops entered Bohemia and Moravia, meeting no
resistance. The Hungarian invasion of Carpatho-Ukraine did encounter resistance, but the Hungarian army quickly crushed it. On
March 16, Hitler went to Czechoslovakia and from Prague's Hradcany Castle proclaimed Bohemia and Moravia a German protectorate (Protectorate of Bohemia and
Moravia).
Thus, independent Czechoslovakia collapsed in the wake of foreign aggression and internal tensions. Subsequently, interwar
Czechoslovakia has been idealized by its proponents as the only bastion of democracy surrounded by authoritarian and fascist
regimes. It has also been condemned by its detractors as an artificial and unworkable creation of intellectuals supported by the
great powers. Both views have some validity. Interwar Czechoslovakia was comprised of lands and peoples that were far from being
integrated into a modern nation-state. Moreover, the dominant Czechs, who had suffered political discrimination under the
Habsburgs, were not able to cope with the demands of other nationalities. In fairness to the Czechs, it should be acknowledged
that some of the minority demands served as mere pretexts to justify intervention by Nazi Germany. That Czechoslovakia was able
under such circumstances to maintain a viable economy and a democratic political system was indeed a remarkable achievement of
the interwar period.
Division of Czechoslovakia
During World War II, Czechoslovakia ceased to exist and was divided into
the Protectorate of Bohemia and
Moravia of the Third Reich and the newly declared Slovak
Republic.
Rationale for Invasion
Czechoslovakia was a major manfucturer of machine guns and had an highly
modernized army. Many of thse factories continued to produce Czech designs until factories were converted for German machine gun
designs. Czechoslovakia also had other major manufacturing concerns. Entire steel and chemical factories were moved from
Czechoslovakia and reassembled in Linz,Austria
which, incidentally remains a heavily industrialized sector of the country. Germany's invasion was motivated by the plundering of
the Czech weapons manufacturing technology and machinery.
Czech Resistance
In exile, Benes—the leader of the Czechoslovak government-in-exile—organized a resistance network. Hacha, Prime
Minister Elias, and the Czech resistance acknowledged Benes's leadership. Active collaboration between London and the
Czechoslovak home front was maintained throughout the war years.
The Czech resistance comprised four main groups:
- The army command coordinated with a multitude of spontaneous groupings to form the Defense of the Nation (Obrana národa--ON)
with branches in Britain and France.
- Benes's collaborators, led by Prokop Drtina, created the Political Center (Politicke ústredí--PU). The PU was nearly
destroyed by arrests in November 1939, after which younger politicians took control.
- Social democrats and leftist intellectuals, in association with such groups as trade-unions and educational institutions,
constituted the Committee of the Petition We Remain Faithful (Peticni vybor Verni zustanme--PVVZ).
- The Communist Party of
Czechoslovakia (KSC) was the fourth resistance group. The KSC had been one of over twenty political parties in the democratic
First Republic, but it had never gained sufficient votes to unsettle the democratic government. After the Munich Agreement the
leadership of the KSC moved to Moscow and the party went underground. Until 1943, however, KSC resistance was weak. The Nazi-Soviet Nonaggression Pact in 1939 had left the KSC in
disarray. But ever faithful to the Soviet line, the KSC began a more active struggle against the Nazis after Germany's attack on
the Soviet Union in June 1941.
The democratic groups--ON, PU, and PVVZ--united in early 1940 and formed the Central Committee of the Home Resistance
(Ustredni vybor odboje domaciho--UVOD). Involved primarily in intelligence gathering, the UVOD cooperated with a Soviet
intelligence organization in Prague. Following the Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union in June 1941, the democratic groups
attempted to create a united front that would include the KSC. Heydrich's appointment in the fall thwarted these efforts. By
mid-1942 the Nazis had succeeded in exterminating the most experienced elements of the Czech resistance forces.
Czech forces regrouped in 1942 and 1943. The Council of the Three (R3), in which the communist underground was strongly
represented, emerged as the focal point of the resistance. The R3 prepared to assist the liberating armies of the United States
and the Soviet Union. In cooperation with Red Army partisan units, the R3 developed a guerrilla structure.
Guerrilla activity intensified after the formation of a provisional Czechoslovak government in Kosice on April 4, 1945. "National
committees" took over the administration of towns as the Germans were expelled. Under the supervision of the Red Army, more than 4,850 such committees were formed between 1944 and the end of the war. On May 5 a national uprising began spontaneously
in Prague, and the newly formed Czech National Council (Ceska narodni rada) almost immediately assumed leadership of the revolt.
Over 1,600 barricades were erected throughout the city, and some 30,000 Czech men and women battled for three days against 37,000
to 40,000 German troops backed by tanks and artillery. On May 8 the German Wehrmacht capitulated; Soviet troops arrived on May
9.
Czechoslovak Government-in-Exile
Benes had resigned as president of the Czechoslovak Republic on October 5,
1938. In London he and other Czechoslovak exiles organized a Czechoslovak
government-in-exile and negotiated to obtain international recognition for the government and a renunciation of the Munich
Agreement and its consequences. Benes hoped for a restoration of the Czechoslovak state in its pre-Munich form after the
anticipated Allied victory. In the summer of 1941, the Allies recognized the exiled
government. In 1942 Allied repudiation of the Munich Agreement established the political
and legal continuity of the First Republic and Benes's presidency.
The Munich Agreement had been precipitated by the subversive activities of the Sudeten Germans. During the latter years of the
war, Benes worked toward resolving the German minority problem and received consent from the Allies for a solution based on a
postwar transfer of the Sudeten German population. The First Republic had been committed to a Western policy in foreign affairs.
The Munich Agreement was the outcome. Benes determined to strengthen Czechoslovak security against future German aggression
through alliances with Poland and the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union, however, objected to a tripartite
Czechoslovak-Polish-Soviet commitment. In December 1943, Benes's government concluded a
treaty with the Soviets.
Benes's interest in maintaining friendly relations with the Soviet Union was motivated also by his desire to avoid Soviet
encouragement of a postwar communist coup
in Czechoslovakia. Benes worked to bring Czechoslovak communist exiles in Britain into active cooperation with his government,
offering far-reaching concessions, including nationalization of heavy industry and the creation of local people's committees at
the war's end. In March 1945, he gave key cabinet positions to Czechoslovak communist
exiles in Moscow.
End of the War
On May 8, 1944, Benes signed an agreement with
Soviet leaders stipulating that Czechoslovak territory liberated by Soviet armies would be placed under Czechoslovak civilian
control
On September 21, Czechoslovak troops formed in the Soviet Union
liberated vilage Kalinov, liberated the
first settlement of Czechoslovakia near the Dukla Pass in northeastern
Slovakia. Czechoslovakia was liberated mostly by Soviet troops (the Red Army), supported by Czech and Slovak resistance, from the
east to the west, only southwestern Bohemia was liberated by other Allied troops from the west. Except for the brutalities of the
German occupation in Bohemia and Moravia (after the August 1944 Slovak National Uprising also in Slovakia), Czechoslovakia suffered relatively little from the
war.
A provisional Czechoslovak government was established in the eastern Slovak town of Kosice on April 4, 1945. "National committees" (supervised by the Red Army) took over
the administration of towns as the Germans were expelled. Bratislava was taken
over on April 4, 1945, and Prague on May 9, 1945 by Soviet troops. Both Soviet and Allied troops were withdrawn in the same year. (The Soviet troops,
however, came back in 1968 (see Prague
Spring) and were withdrawn only in the early 1990s).
Annexation of Carpatho-Ukraine (Subcarpathian Ruthenia) by the Soviet
Union
In October 1944,
Carpatho-Ukraine was taken by the Soviets. A Czechoslovak delegation under František Nemec was dispatched to the area. The
delegation was to mobilize the liberated local population to form a Czechoslovak army and to prepare for elections in cooperation
with recently established national committees. Loyalty to a Czechoslovak state was tenuous in Carpatho-Ukraine. Benes's
proclamation of April 1944 excluded former collaborationist Hungarians, Germans, and the Russophile Ruthenian followers of
Andrej Brody and the Fencik Party (who had collaborated with
the Hungarians) from political participation. This amounted to approximately one-third of the population. Another one-third was
communist, leaving one-third of the population presumably sympathetic to the Czechoslovak Republic.
Upon arrival in Carpatho-Ukraine, the Czechoslovak delegation set up headquarters in Khust and on October 30 issued a mobilization proclamation. Soviet military forces prevented both the printing and the
posting of the Czechoslovak proclamation and proceeded instead to organize the local population. Protests from Benes's government
went unheeded. Soviet activities led much of the local population to believe that Soviet annexation was imminent. The
Czechoslovak delegation was also prevented from establishing a cooperative relationship with the local national committees
promoted by the Soviets. On November 19, the communists, meeting in Mukachevo, issued a resolution requesting separation of Carpatho-Ukraine from
Czechoslovakia and incorporation into the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic. On November 26, the Congress of National Committees unanimously accepted the resolution of the communists. The
congress elected the National Council and instructed that a delegation be sent to Moscow to discuss union. The Czechoslovak
delegation was asked to leave Carpatho-Ukraine. Negotiations between the Czechoslovak government and Moscow ensued. Both Czech
and Slovak communists encouraged Benes to cede Carpatho-Ukraine. The Soviet Union agreed to postpone annexation until the postwar
period to avoid compromising Benes's policy based on the pre-Munich frontiers.
The treaty ceding Carpatho-Ukraine to the Soviet Union was signed in June 1945. Czechs and Slovaks living in Carpatho-Ukraine
and Ukrainians (Ruthenians) living in Czechoslovakia were given the choice of Czechoslovak or Soviet citizenship.
Minorities and Population Transfers
The Czechoslovak National Front coalition government, formed at Kosice in April 1945, issued decrees providing for the
expulsion of all Sudeten Germans with the exception of those who had demonstrated loyalty to the republic. German property would
be confiscated without compensation. All officials of the SdP, or the Sudeten Nazis, and all members of the Nazi Security Police
would be prosecuted.
In May 1945, Czechoslovak troops took possession of the Sudetenland. A Czechoslovak administrative commission composed
exclusively of Czechs was established. Sudeten Germans were subjected to restrictive measures and conscripted for compulsory
labor to repair war damages. Individual acts of retaliation against Germans and precipitous expulsion under harsh conditions
characterized the immediate aftermath of the occupation. On June 15, however, Benes
called Czechoslovak authorities to order. In July Czechoslovak representatives addressed the Potsdam Conference (the United States, Britain, and the Soviet Union) and presented plans for a
humane and orderly transfer of the Sudeten German population.
The Potsdam Agreement provided for the resettlement of Sudeten
Germans in Germany under the supervision of the Allied Control Council. The transfer began in January 1946. By December 31, 1946, some 1.7 million Germans had
been resettled in the American Zone and 750,000 in the Soviet Zone. Approximately 225,000 Germans remained in Czechoslovakia, of
whom 50,000 emigrated or were expelled soon after.
The Potsdam Agreement pertained to Germans only. Decisions regarding the Hungarian minority reverted to the Czechoslovak
government. The resettlement of about 700,000 Hungarians was envisaged at Kosice and subsequently reaffirmed by the National
Front. Budapest, however, opposed a unilateral transfer. In February 1946, the Hungarian
government agreed that Czechoslovakia could expatriate as many Hungarians as there were Slovaks in Hungary wishing to return to
Czechoslovakia. As a result, 89,660 people were resettled from Czechoslovakia to Hungary, and 71,787 in the opposite direction,
by 1948.
Territory ceded to Poland in 1938 and restored to Slovakia after the Nazi invasion of Poland, in accordance with the terms of
the German-Slovak agreement of November 21, 1939, became part of the restored Czechoslovak state in 1945. The Polish minority (100,000) were declared full civil
liberties. However, the minority organisations were restricted and their property confiscated.
|